Building the Company

Slicing Pie

Fund Your Company Without Funds

Mike Moyer · 2012 · Self-published

A dynamic, contribution-based way to split founder equity before there is money to pay anyone, with clear rules for when people leave.

The big idea

What the book argues

Moyer argues that fixed equity splits agreed on day one are guesses about future contributions, and those guesses are usually wrong. His alternative, the Grunt Fund, tracks every unpaid contribution of time, cash, equipment or relationships at fair market value, weights it for risk, and gives each person a share equal to their portion of the total. The split adjusts as work happens, then freezes into a normal cap table once the company can pay people or raises a priced round.

2x
multiplier on non-cash contributions such as unpaid salary
4x
multiplier on cash contributed to the company

Key takeaways

6 ideas worth keeping

1

Fixed splits predict the future and usually miss

An equal split on day one assumes everyone will contribute equally for years. In practice one person goes part-time, another puts in cash, a third leaves. The frozen split then feels unfair to someone, and resentment or legal fights follow. Moyer compares it to splitting gambling winnings evenly when the players bet very different amounts.

2

Ownership tracks the contributions people actually make

In the Grunt Fund, each uncompensated contribution earns slices. Your share at any moment is your slices divided by all slices. Because it updates as contributions land, nobody has to renegotiate when roles change; contributing more simply raises your share. The model applies to time, cash, supplies, facilities, ideas that become real work, and introductions that produce results.

3

Risk multipliers put cash and time on one scale

Non-cash contributions, such as unpaid salary, are multiplied by two; cash is multiplied by four because it is scarcer and more directly at risk. The multipliers convert very different sacrifices into a single unit so they can be compared fairly. The higher weight on cash reflects that money handed over is gone if the company fails, while forgone salary was never received in the first place.

Illustration: Forgoing $10,000 of market-rate salary earns 20,000 slices (2x). Investing $5,000 cash earns the same 20,000 slices (4x).
4

Use market value, not founder opinion

Each contribution is priced at what it would cost on the open market: time at the salary the person could realistically earn elsewhere, minus any pay received; space at its rental rate; equipment at its value. Using observable prices turns arguments about who matters more into arithmetic. An idea alone, without the work to develop it, earns modest credit.

5

How someone leaves decides what they keep

Moyer's recovery rules address dead equity. If someone is let go without cause or resigns for good reason, they keep their slices. If they are fired for cause or quit without good reason, they lose their non-cash slices, and the company can buy back cash contributions. This prevents an early departure from holding a large stake while others build the value.

6

Freeze the pie once people can be paid

The dynamic model is meant for the period before the company can pay market compensation. When it reaches breakeven or raises a meaningful priced round, contributions are no longer at risk, so the split freezes and converts to standard shares with vesting. Every percentage on the resulting cap table has a documented history behind it.

The framework

Slicing Pie recovery rules

How the person leavesNon-cash slicesCash slices
Terminated without causeKeptKept
Resigns for good reasonKeptKept
Terminated for causeForfeitedCompany may buy back at cash value
Resigns without good reasonForfeitedCompany may buy back at cash value

Apply it this week

Three moves to make now

  1. Set up a shared spreadsheet logging date, person, contribution type, market value, multiplier and slices, and update it weekly.
  2. Agree in writing on market salary rates for each contributor and on the recovery rules before anyone starts working unpaid.
  3. Set the freeze trigger in advance, such as breakeven or closing a priced round, and plan the conversion to vested shares.

Read next

Pairs well with

This page is an original summary and commentary prepared by XRAYCLOUD.AI with AI assistance. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by the author or publisher, and it is no substitute for the book — read it for the full argument.